Yeovil Town came within a whisker of being on the end of an FA Cup giant-killing after a late Johl Powell equaliser saw them forced to a fourth qualifying round replay at Huish Park on Tuesday night.
The Glovers looked to be home and dry after Archie Davies and Brett McGavin put them 2-0 up with goals either side of a missed penalty from McGavin in the second half, but when Leatherhead captain Mark Waters pulled a goal back with 77 minutes on the clock, the home crowd sensed an FA Cup shock.
The atmosphere inside Fetcham Grove seemed to spur the home side and exploded when Waters pulled them level and then fired them ahead. A giant-killing looked to be on the cards before Powell steered home an equaliser with a minute of normal time remaining.
First half
Yeovil Town named another unchanged starting XI for the third consecutive game with the only change coming on the substitutes’ bench where Owen Dean dropped out having played for Farnham Town in the competition’s earlier rounds.
The possession statistics must have been almost perfect for the visitors in the opening 20 minutes with the Glovers passing the ball around beautifully with Leatherhead playing like the away side looking to hit on the break.
On eight minutes, James Daly smashed an effort in to the side netting and then with 22 minutes gone, a powerful run by Daly down left played in Johl Powell who was denied by hosts’ keeper Sonny Wheeler before Niran Butler hacked it clear.
For the Tanners, winger Anas Igozouln was a threat down the right and came in for some rough treatment notably from Yeovil captain Brett McGavin who was perhaps fortunate to get away with a yellow card for his challenge on 25 minutes.

There were nervous moments when striker Tom Dryer broke through the Yeovil defence with eight minutes of the first half remaining. It was only a combination of goalkeeper Jos Barker and Jordan Norville-Williams saw the danger away, but only far enough for the hosts to flash a cross in front of the visitors’ goal.
There was some good last ditch defending from the home side, but aside from the Powell effort there was not a meaningful chance on the Leatherhead goal. There was a deep and meaningful conversation between Billy Rowley and his assistant Darren Simpson before they went back in to the dressing room at the interval.
Half-time: Leatherhead 0 Yeovil Town 0
Second half
Any fans who stayed a minute later in the bar at half-time would have been disappointed as Yeovil took the lead in the opening minute of the second half. It was the type of good passing move which we had seen plenty of in the opening 45 minutes which allowed Archie DAVIES to get in on the right and smash a low shot home for the opener.

Then three minutes later there was a golden opportunity for the visitors to double the advantage when Daly went over inside the box and referee James Durkin pointed to the spot. Brett McGavin stepped up and smashed his penalty against the underside of the crossbar and away.
But the captain found the back just before the hour mark. Ryan Jones weaved in from the left and looked set to shoot before laying it back to Brett McGAVIN who hammered home.
With the score line looking more comfortable, Rowley rang the changes with four changes as Joe Gubbins, Charlie Lennon, Mason Obeng and Ste Walker coming on.
There were opportunities for both Davies and Obeng to put the game out of reach of the hosts and they were chances which would come back to haunt the visitors when Leatherhead pulled a goal back with 13 minutes remaining. A free-kick in from the right side saw Jos Barker come for it and miss, the ball was headed back across goal where Lewis PAGET headed one back.
Full time: Leatherhead 3 Yeovil Town 3
Match Details
Venue: Fetcham Grove
Date: Saturday 17th October, 2026, 3pm
Competition: FA Cup fourth qualifying round
Scorers: Archie Davies 46 (1-0), Brett McGavin 58 (2-0), Paget 77 (1-2), Waters 81 (2-2), Waters 86 (3-2), Powell 89 (3-3)
Conditions: Dry and sunny
Pitch: Glorious and only a little slopey in the goal mouths
Attendance: 2000 (400 Yeovil)
Bookings:
Yeovil Town: McGavin ’25
Leatherhead: Waters ‘ 90
Referee: James Durkin
Yeovil Town
Substitutes: Loick Ayina, Joe Gubbins, Charlie Lennon, Ste Walker, Matt Gould.












2 up on 75 mins, how many buses did Rowley park!!! My home score sheet shows that this is the 5th time this season that we have conceded !!!!
Tell me you weren’t at the game without telling me you weren’t at the game
Should read conceded late